PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin


War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires

War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires Characters â PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Tes But as empires grow the rich get richer and the poor get poorer conflict replaces cooperation and dissolution inevitably follows Elouently argued and rich with historical examples War and Peace and War offers a bold new theory about the course of world history. I am the kind of person who is always seeking a set of abstract principles within which to contextualize my experience of events and information This characteristic has often dampened my enthusiasm for the study of history since my encounters with history books usually amount to poring over lists of occurrences with only the occasional idea or theme that ties everything together I m also aware that my predilection for abstraction is a potential handicap when applied to history it can be intellectually dangerous to reduce the past to a mere set of rules or lessons and this activity usually steamrolls the complexity of real life in favor of easy explanationsMy ideal historian therefore should represent the best of both worlds a mind steeped in the rich diversity of historical events that is also capable of distilling those events into evidence based concepts that withstand serious scrutiny and hold up across time I am aware of no author who accomplishes this with greater success than Peter Turchin in War and Peace and War I consider this the single best history book I ve read to dateTurchin is the creator of a new field of study called Cliodynamics which he defines as a new science of historical dynamics 10 Cliodynamics is a cyclical interpretation of history that focuses on the relationship between three core types of historical cycles asabiya cycles this wonderful term originates from 14th century thinker Ibn Khaldoun secular cycles and fathers and sons cycles Out of respect for the richness of Turchin s theory I will uote him at length in order to demonstrate how these cycles are distinct from as well as interactive with one anotherA general theory for the rise and decline of empires we have The crucial variable in it is the collective capacity for action the society s asabiya Competition between societies leads to asabiya increase whereas competition within a society causes its asabiya to decline As we have seen in Part I of this book metaethnic frontiers where groups and civilizations clash are the crucibles within which high asabiya societies are forged The almost inevitable conseuence of high capacity for collective action however is territorial expansion that pushes the frontiers away from the center and removes the very forces that fostered high asabiya in the first place Thus success breeds eventual failure the rise carries within it the seeds of the fall peace brings war and war brings peace In the language of nonlinear dynamics rise and fall phenomena are explained by negative feedback loopsDecline of asabiya is not a linear process As we now know empires go through long secular cycles of alternating integrative disintegrative phases Within society competition wanes during the integrative phase and waxes during the disintegrative phase It is during disintegrative phases when the asabiya of the society takes a big hit Further one disintegrative phase is usually not enough to completely degrade the cohesion of a high asabiya society It typically takes two or three secular cycles for an imperial nation to lose its capacity for concerted actionHowever even this portrayal is an oversimplification Disintegrative phases are also not uniformly bad Because people get fed up with constant instability and insecurity civil warfare during an instability phase tends to skip a generation the children of revolutionaries want to avoid disorder at any cost but the grandchildren of revolutionaries are ready to repeat the mistakes of their grandparents all over again As a result disintegration phases tend to go through two or three fathers and sons cycles before a renaissance can take hold and the society can enter a secular integrative phaseThe dynamics of imperial rise and decline therefore are like a mechanism with wheels within wheels within wheels The waxing and waning of asabiya is the slowest process taking many centuries often a millennium for a complete cycle Secular cycles occur on a faster time scale A typical imperial nation goes through two or three and sometimes even four secular cycles during the course of its life Finally the disintegrative phase of each secular cycle will see two or three waves of political instability and civil warfare separated by periods of fragile peace The characteristic time scales therefore are a millennium for the asabiya cycle 2 to 3 centuries for a secular cycle and 40 to 60 years two generations for fathers and sons cycles These are just orders of magnitude there is no exact periodicity in any of these processes 285 6While Cliodynamics has significant implications for many areas of historical study Turchin restricts War and Peace and War to an examination of empires which he defines as large multiethnic territorial states withcomplex power structures 3 The vision is grand but Turchin is careful to repeatedly point out the limitations of his arguments and also considers alternative explanations even when he finds them unsatisfactoryTurchin s distinct ability to lay out an ambitious and expansive theory while remaining appropriately humble is most likely a result of his interdisciplinary approach It s up to each reader to decide if this methodology confers special legitimacy or reveals a lack of sufficient commitment to the traditions of academic historians but I found myself suarely in the former camp In a daring feat of intellectual synthesis Turchin shores up his historical research with evidence from myriad areas of science including but not limited to evolutionary theory economics statistical mechanics nonlinear dynamics geopolitics social psychology demographics chaos theory and physics His numerous applications of modern discoveries to historical documents and datasets is engrossing and uniue compared to other historians I ve read As he notes than a few times History is too complex for single factor explanations 29 War and Peace and War bears out this creed proving itself a true marriage of modern and ancient wisdomThe basics of Cliodynamics are enough to make this book a worthwhile read for anyone but there are many additional insights that Turchin manages to cram into this dense but digestible text The resurrection of Khaldoun s concept of asabiya is invaluable Turchin acknowledges that a group s asabiya is a dynamic uantity that cannot be observed directly but it can be measured from observable conseuences 6 This is unlikely to mollify hard nosed evolutionary biologists seeking an ironclad mathematical model to verify or deny asabiya s existence but it does represent a beautiful articulation of a missing link in our evolutionary thinking that has only recently been revitalized by proponents of multilevel selectionThe application of asabiya to our understanding of identity and citizenship holds tremendous potential for community building on every level of human organization Turchin observes that A nation with high collective solidarity can lose many battles and still prevail in the end but this clearly seems to hold for human groups across the board 103 This profoundly humanist idea reminds us that while the differences between individuals and groups should never be ignored they should also never be allowed to blot out the deeper truth that all human undertakings are inherently collective with the best societies achieving solidarity over time by harnessing diversity s upsides and declawing its downsides Getting along with others isn t just nice it s essential for survivalOne critical aspect of asabiya that Turchin examines is how symbolic markers language and dialect religion and ritualistic behaviors race clothing behavioral mannerisms hairstyles ornaments and tattoos can either bring people together or keep them apart 5 emphasis his All symbolic markers play a dual role of 1 providing a space in which solidarity can be discovered or embellished and 2 signaling indifference or outright hostility to members of out groups Over time and given sufficient survival pressures certain markers can leap the chasm between us and them often acuiring new powers of influence in the resolution or incitement of disputesAnother of Turchin s fascinating findings involves the characteristics of metaethnic frontiers tense borderlands that serve as make or break points for rising or declining empires Turchin shows how borderlands provide a dramatic stage on which one of two basic dynamics will prevail 1 the empire s centralized government will bolster its most vulnerable citizens by helping them absorb or dispel barbarians thereby reinforcing or expanding its capacity for asabiya or 2 those same barbarians will successfully challenge the empire s claim to fringe territory thereby diminishing the empire s asabiya If this latter dynamic persists long enough new bonds of identification and mutual understanding can arise between the empire s disenchanted subjects and the barbarians generating a new locus of asabiya that may ultimately subvert andor rise up to destroy the empire and give birth to a new one Turchin s granular focus on Roman history is the main arena where he illustrates this dynamic but he also pulls effective examples from the histories of the United States Russia China the Middle East and othersTurchin is keenly aware that empires do not rise and fall purely because of external factors In fact Cliodynamics argues that internal factors are often important when an empire s fate is decided Central to this view are the tensions that arise between as well as within classes in any given empire The integrative phases of secular cycles tend to be egalitarian with relatively eual wealth distribution and higher rates of social mobility Disintegrative phases by contrast are marked by increasing ineuality and intense inter as well as intra class competition Turchin explainsWhen rich get richer and poor get poorer cooperation between social classes is undermined But the same process is operating within each class When some nobles are growing conspicuously wealthy while the majority of nobility is increasingly impoverished the elites become riven by factional conflicts Within the secular cycle as the disintegrative phase follows the integrative one ineuality rises and falls A life cycle of an imperial nation usually extends over the course of two or three or even four secular cycles Every time the empire enters a disintegrative secular phase the asabiya of its core nation is significantly degraded Eventually this process of imperiopathosis reaches its terminal phase the imperial nation loses its ability to cooperate and the empire collapses Most empires therefore fall for internal reasons 281Fluctuations in population and economic markets the development of new technologies political revolutions and forces of nature such as climate and disease can slow down or speed up these processes but the general trends of the secular cycle tend to reliably recur over timeWhile I consider War and Peace and War to be a superb book there are a few areas where I think Turchin s perspective is incorrect or needs augmentation Turchin fumbles badly when it comes to the matter of physical determinism and free will falling prey to the all too common conflation of randomness and freedomParticles at the subatomic level behave in a stochastic completely erratic and unpredictable manner and modern physics has been unable to reduce their behavior to the action of deterministic laws It is uite possible that the universe at some very basic level is not deterministic at allAt a lower level uantum physics tells us that the behavior of subatomic particles cannot be predicted that is they have a kind of free will 311 317In my view randomness denotes the limit of humanity s ability to make precise observational predictions and not a fundamental breakdown of deterministic physical laws The randomness of uantum activity is therefore completely compatible with determinism even if it thwarts our predictive efforts Randomness is not compatible however with free will The fact that an outcome can t be predicted from an external perspective does not mean any kind of choice or rupture in causality is happening either at the subatomic level or any other So while I disagree with Turchin s contention that people have free will I heartily agree with him that free will in this context is a red herring Whether people have free will or nothas nothing to do with our ability to understand and predict historical dynamics 317 This makes one wonder why Turchin bothered to include any discussion of free will in the first placeTurchin s fortifications are also lacking on two other fronts but both are errors of omission rather than misinterpretation of facts In his final chapters Turchin invites us to consider the implications of Cliodynamics for modern empires It is an enlightening and generally well framed discussion but Turchin ignores two game changing modern developments artificial intelligenceautomation and anthropogenic climate change It is possible he sidesteps these topics because they represent unprecedented challenges that preclude credible prediction based on past events or perhaps AIautomation and climate change weren t as front and center in the mid 2000s as they are nowAll of these faults are easily forgiven in the greater context of Turchin s laudable contribution to the discipline of historical analysis It follows that his assessment of modernity deserves our careful consideration He claims that the era of empires is certainly not over and makes a strong case that the United States the European Union and China all ualify as contemporary empires Russia is a borderline case Turchin is forthright regarding the possible flaws in his theories that will need correction by others and eschews fatalism by remaining open to the possibility that humanity may one day escape the historical cycles that have dominated our story thus far To that end he gestures toward a host of recent developments our move away from agrarian economies the development of the Internet and mobile phones and the invention of heterarchical nonhierarchical power structures amongst others that may compound or subvert the patterns of CliodynamicsLike any great thinker Turchin knows he is but one tiny incarnation of humanity s intellectual potential seeking merely to make a worthy contribution This he has certainly achieved and in doing so he has also illuminated each person s mysterious but undeniable potential to do the sameMicro actions by most people most of the time have no effect whatsoever on the behavior of the system as a whole they are completely dampened out at the macro level But sometimes an individual acts in a place and at a time where the macrosystem is extremely sensitive to small perturbations Then a little act of a little individual can trigger an avalanche of conseuences and result in a complete change of the course of events The childhood rhyme For want of a nail illustrates this idea perfectlyThis is an optimistic conclusion because it suggests that not all individual action is doomed to be futile at the macro level of social systems There is no excuse in not trying to be good because even if most of such actions would probably dissipate without any lasting effect once in a while a small action will have a large effect 319 20This review was originally published on my blog wordsdirt

Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin

War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires Characters â PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Y’s capacity for collective action He demonstrates that high levels of cooperation are found where people have to band together to fight off a common enemy and that this kind of cooperation led to the formation of the Roman and Russian empires and the United Sta. In this book Turchin attempts a familiar task trying to discern laws of history In this particular case Turchin generalizes about the formation rise and fall of empiresAlisdair MacIntyre it seems to me proved that social science in the sense of prediction is impossible in principleThat doesn t mean we can t discern cycles and causative factors in human history but only that we must be very cautious about how complete and accurate our conclusions are Turchin supplies some disclaimersHis basic notions are that empires arise on one side or the other of a metaethnic frontier say that between the Romans and first the Celts and then the German and Hunnish barbarians to their northeast The need to resist contributes to an increase in asabiya a concept gleaned from the Maghrebi scholar Ibn Khaldun social solidarity or lessAs ineuality increases and lites become too bloated asabiya declines and crime and civil war increase leading to war epidemic and anarchy The lite s size shrinks and the reduced population of peons and proles improves their market position and standard of living thus increasing asabiyaTurchin supports this theory with examples from historyThe book is uite readable and the hypotheses plausible if not entirely new see eg the work of Spengler Pitirim Sorokin etc

Peter Turchin » 2 Characters

War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires Characters â PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Like Jared Diamond in Guns Germs and Steel Peter Turchin in War and Peace and War uses his expertise in evolutionary biology to make a highly original argument about the rise and fall of empires Turchin argues that the key to the formation of an empire is a societ. This is a compelling read on world history with some interesting views Turchin develops his own theories on the rise and fall of empires especially in the pre modern period empires always developed in places near a border with another group or a state that was perceived as fundamentally different and threatening and their strength corresponded with their internal social cohesion This are not completely original views as he concedes but he intertwines them and elaborates on them in his own way Finally he also very much pleads for the use of theoretical models in the study of history along his own Cliodynamic approach that is founded on uantitative data Very interesting and very worthwile but also tricky if you ask me See my elaborate review on this book in my Sense of History account on Goodreads

  • Paperback
  • 416
  • War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires
  • Peter Turchin
  • English
  • 05 May 2018
  • 9780452288195

10 thoughts on “PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin

  1. says: Read War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin Peter Turchin » 2 Characters

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin I'm a bit skeptical of Big History books primarily because the world we live in today is so radically different from the cyclical political orde

  2. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin Read War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin This is a compelling read on world history with some interesting views Turchin develops his own theories on the rise and fall of empires especially in the pre modern period empires always developed in places near a border

  3. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Subtitle The Rise and Fall of EmpiresSo as you may have heard me say before the books I read can mostly be divided into two types Big Idea books

  4. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Peter Turchin » 2 Characters

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Very interesting but as frustrating as it is challengingThe title of this book is a bit misleading it does indeed regularly deal with war and peace and with the rise and fall of imperia but actually Turchin cover

  5. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Read War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin In this book Turchin attempts a familiar task trying to discern laws of history In this particular case Turchin generalizes about the formation rise and fall of empiresAlisdair MacIntyre it seems to me proved that social science in

  6. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin

    Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin Peter Turchin » 2 Characters PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin A fascinating group selectionist take on the dynamics of the rise and fall of empires in history

  7. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Peter Turchin » 2 Characters Yet another Big History book this one really pulled out in front of the pack for me and I think it's the best one I've read so farFirst there's no better way to make me smile than with a reference to psychohistory from my favorite sci fi series of all time Turchin compares his goal of scientifying history to Asimov's famou

  8. says: Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin

    Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin I am the kind of person who is always seeking a set of abstract principles within which to contextualize my experience of events and information This characteristic has often dampened my enthusiasm for the study of history since my encounters with history books usually amount to poring over lists of occurrences with only the occasional idea or theme that ties everything together I’m also aware that my predilection for abstraction is a

  9. says: PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin Peter Turchin » 2 Characters Turchin begins by referring to Hari Selden the mastermind of psychohistory in Isaac Asimov's Foundation Trilogy in describing his project a logical cause effect analysis of how where when why great empires are born their life cycle and finally their decline fall In a nutshell he finds it's all about social cohesiveness Turchin's style becomes somewhat turgid tedious but his thesis has merit This is worth plowing thru

  10. says: Read War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires Download ´ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free » Peter Turchin Peter Turchin » 2 Characters

    PDF NEW War and Peace and War The Rise and Fall of Empires ò Peter Turchin History is a spiral it always repeat itself but each time the loop is a bit different from the previous

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *